Should You Invest in That? A CFO’s Guide to Smarter Business Decisions

I’ve seen a common challenge crop up time and again: how to confidently decide whether a business investment is worth it.

Whether you’re considering a new piece of equipment, expanding your premises, hiring a salesperson, or upgrading systems, every one of these decisions has something in common: they’re investments. And the stakes can be high.

→ What is an Investment, Really?
→ The Types of Investments You’ll Face
→ A Smarter Way to Decide: Protection and Performance
→ The Mindset Behind Great Decisions

What is an Investment, Really?

At its core, an investment is simple: it’s about spending money today with the expectation of a greater return tomorrow. That return might come in the form of increased revenue, reduced costs, improved efficiency, or stronger market position. But it’s still a bet on the future.

And we all know one thing about the future: there are no guarantees.

The Types of Investments You’ll Face

Most business owners immediately think of tangible assets. New machinery, tools, vehicles. These are often easier to measure. But many of the most powerful investments are less visible:

• Hiring a revenue-generating employee

• Launching a new product

• Investing in training or systems

• Rebranding or marketing

Each comes with its own risks, and each can either propel your business forward - or drain cash with little to show for it.

A Smarter Way to Decide: Protection and Performance

We’ve developed a practical, two-part framework that helps clients make investment decisions with clarity and confidence. It boils down to two key areas:

1. Protection: Can We Afford to Get This Wrong?

Before looking at the upside, we first ask: How do we protect our downside?

This means:

• Understanding our current financial position. Are we cashflow stable? Do we have buffer room?

• Assessing the risk exposure. If this fails, what’s the damage? Are we risking the farm?

• Structuring the investment. Can we stage it? Pilot it? Negotiate terms that reduce upfront cost or exposure?

It’s about ensuring that, even if the investment doesn’t go to plan, the business can keep operating. This mindset of “protect first” is often overlooked, but it’s crucial.

2. Performance: What’s the Potential Upside?

Once we’re confident the risk is controlled, we can turn to the exciting part. What happens if it works?

This involves:

• Projecting revenue or efficiency gains

• Estimating timelines for payback or ROI

• Considering strategic value (like gaining a competitive edge or future-proofing the business)

But here’s the key: assume reasonable expectations.

We’re not forecasting doomsday, but we’re also not assuming that your new hire will triple your revenue in six weeks. We aim for a balanced, informed view of the likely outcome because that’s where smart decisions are made.

The Mindset Behind Great Decisions

One final point—successful investment decisions aren’t made from a place of fear or fantasy. They come from grounded, methodical thinking. They’re made when we have access to the right information, can see both sides of the equation, and know we’re protecting what we’ve already built.

That’s the work we do with clients every day. And it’s a mindset I encourage every business owner to embrace.

If you’re facing an investment decision and want clarity, support, or just a second set of eyes, let’s have a conversation.

Subscribe to our newsletter

For more tips on increasing revenue and profitability, sign up to our newsletter for business owners, leaders, and finance team managers. Each week, you'll get practical, no-fluff tips and insights in short, easy videos. No corporate jargon, no time wasting. Sign up now.