Why Every Business Needs a Salary Cap
If you’re into sport, you’ll know what a salary cap is. It’s a simple but powerful idea: a team is allowed to spend up to a certain limit on its players’ wages.
You can split it however you like—stack one superstar and spread the rest thin, or share it out evenly—but there’s a hard ceiling. Cross that line, and you’re in breach. The penalties are serious: fines, stripped titles, or even being kicked out of the league.
Now, let me ask you: why don’t we treat our businesses the same way?
IN THIS ARTICLE:
→ The Hiring Trap: More People ≠ More Profit
→ Finding Your Business’ Salary Cap
→ How to Use the Salary Cap Mentality in Your Business
→ Efficiency Isn’t Just About Cost—It’s About Output
→ When the Numbers Don’t Add Up
→ A Reality Check for Growth-Driven Teams
→ How an Outsourced CFO Helps You Stay on Track
The Hiring Trap: More People ≠ More Profit
One of the most common conversations I hear in businesses—especially growing ones—is, “We need more people.” It’s almost a reflex. Got a bottleneck? Hire someone. Sales not moving fast enough? Add to the team. Want to scale? Bring in more staff.
But here’s the truth: throwing more bodies at a problem doesn’t necessarily make your business more efficient. In fact, in many cases, it just increases your overhead and complicates the operation.
That’s where the salary cap mentality becomes so valuable.
Instead of thinking, “What else do we need?”, we start asking, “What can we achieve with what we’ve got—and how do we maximise that?” It’s a smarter way to think about team building, resource planning, and profitability.
Finding Your Business’ Salary Cap
Every business has its own natural rhythm—times when it just runs well. Not perfect, not overworked, but humming. That’s where your baseline lives. One way to identify this is by tracking your labour cost as a percentage of revenue.
We worked with a client who, over a four-year period, consistently kept their total labour cost—including wages and superannuation—between 14% and 16% of revenue. That figure became their internal salary cap. It wasn’t about cost-cutting; it was about recognising when the business was running efficiently.
Later, as they expanded, they crept up to 22–23%. That might not sound like a massive jump, but in real terms, it was a 30% drop in efficiency. More people, more cost, but the revenue hadn’t followed. The balance was out.
That’s the trigger for a salary cap conversation.
How to Use the Salary Cap Mentality in Your Business
This isn’t theory—it’s incredibly practical. You can use it in two simple ways:
-
Start with revenue goals
If your target is $10 million in revenue, and your ideal labour cost is 16%, then you can afford to spend $1.6 million in wages. That’s your cap. -
Start with current labour cost
If you’re already spending $1.6 million in wages, then work backwards. At 16%, you need to be generating $10 million in revenue to justify that spend.
This gives you a concrete, measurable framework. It removes the emotion from hiring decisions and shifts the conversation toward efficiency and return on investment.
Efficiency Isn’t Just About Cost—It’s About Output
When you impose a salary cap, your team is forced to think differently. They start looking at process improvement, automation, better training, smarter use of systems. They start solving problems instead of outsourcing them through recruitment.
Let’s say you’ve broken your business into four functions—operations, sales, marketing, and admin. If each area knows their historical efficiency levels and understands their budget limits, they can work within those constraints and still deliver results. This accountability creates ownership, and ownership breeds performance.
And crucially—it doesn’t mean you don’t hire.
It means you only hire when the output justifies the cost. It means you’re investing in people, not just accumulating them.
When the Numbers Don’t Add Up
Let’s imagine your team is costing you $1.6 million in wages, but you’re only bringing in $7 million in revenue. That’s a red flag. Either:
-
Your pricing is wrong
-
Your product margins are too slim
-
Your team isn’t efficient
-
Or your cost structure needs a review
Whatever the case, it’s a sign that something in the model needs to be revisited. That’s not a staffing issue—it’s a structural one. And that’s where having a clear benchmark helps you avoid rash decisions.
A Reality Check for Growth-Driven Teams
When your team is clear on what the cap is, they begin to self-regulate. Growth doesn’t mean carte blanche for headcount. It means better use of existing capacity, stronger systems, and better forecasting.
And perhaps the most important point: this isn’t about restriction—it’s about sustainability. A sports team that stays under the cap wins on consistency. A business that sticks to its salary cap wins on profitability, agility, and resilience.
How an Outsourced CFO Helps You Stay on Track
At CFO Dynamics, we work with business owners and leadership teams to build clarity around cost, output, and strategy. The salary cap model is one of the most effective tools we use to help clients improve efficiency without stifling growth.
An outsourced CFO can:
-
Help you identify when your business was running at peak efficiency
-
Analyse historical labour cost ratios
-
Create a tailored salary cap model that aligns to your growth goals
-
Support your managers in making better, data-driven hiring decisions
-
Spot early signs of margin compression before they hurt your bottom line
It’s not about slashing budgets or freezing hiring. It’s about setting healthy, high-performing guardrails so your business can grow sustainably, profitably, and confidently.
So, next time someone suggests adding another person to the team, ask the question:
“Does this help us hit our goals within the cap—or are we just crossing the line?”
Learn everything we teach our clients... for free
Join 400+ business owners & leaders who receive practical business & accounting tips, delivered free to your inbox every week. No fluff, just high-level expertise. Sign up now.
